The Cordless Carver: How a $69 Router Tells the Story of the Modern Workshop

Update on Aug. 18, 2025, 4:25 p.m.

The sound is unmistakable: a high-pitched, turbine-like whine that builds to a crescendo as the bit makes contact with wood. A fine spray of dust erupts, tracing the path of the tool as it transforms a simple, sharp edge into an elegant curve, or carves a precise groove where two pieces will join in perfect harmony. This is the magic of the woodworking router, a tool so versatile it has been called “a complete woodshop in one tool”. It can shape, cut, and sculpt, acting as a table saw, chisel, and plane all in one powerful device. For generations of woodworkers, this transformative power came with a literal string attached: the power cord. A constant tether, the cord was a source of frustration and limitation, snagging on workbenches, dictating the flow of work, and restricting the creator’s movement.

The advent of cordless technology represents more than just a convenience; it is a fundamental liberation. The ability to pick up a tool and use it anywhere, unencumbered by the nearest electrical outlet, has profoundly reshaped the modern workshop. At the heart of this revolution is a confluence of advanced battery chemistry, sophisticated motor design, and strategic product engineering. To understand these forces, one need not look to the most expensive, feature-laden tool on the market. Instead, a more revealing story is told by a far more humble device: the Ryobi P601 One+ 18V Cordless Fixed Base Trim Router.

This report will position the Ryobi P601 not as the most powerful or advanced router available, but as a uniquely important artifact of our time. Its design, its aggressive $69 price point, and its critical place within a sprawling ecosystem of hundreds of other tools make it a perfect case study. By dissecting this unassuming green tool, we can uncover the key technological forces, the deliberate engineering trade-offs, and the brilliant market strategies that define the modern power tool landscape. It is a story that begins over a century ago, with a tool that looked more like a primitive farm implement than a precision instrument.
 Ryobi P601 Cordless Compact Router

Section 1: From “Grandma’s Tooth” to the “Wonder Tool”: A Century of Shaping Wood

The power to hollow out an area in a hard material like wood or plastic—the fundamental act of “routing”—is not a new concept. Long before electric motors whirred to life in workshops, craftsmen relied on a simple, effective hand tool to perform this task: the router plane.

The Humble Origins

The earliest ancestor of the modern router was a masterclass in simplicity. The router plane was, in its most basic form, a chisel held at an adjustable vertical depth within a block of wood or metal. Its primary function was to level out the bottoms of joints, ensuring a precise and consistent depth for dadoes, mortises for hinges, or decorative inlays. These early, often shop-made tools earned an evocative nickname that speaks to their rudimentary appearance: the “old woman’s tooth,” or “Grandma’s Tooth”. While effective for fine-tuning joinery, they were slow, laborious, and dependent entirely on the strength and skill of the user. The desire for more speed and power was a natural evolution.

The Dawn of the Electric Age

The incremental journey toward the modern power router began with foot-pedal operated devices in the late 19th century, but the true leap forward occurred at the dawn of the 20th. In 1905, the Kelly Electric Machine Co. of Buffalo, New York, patented and produced the first commercially available portable power router. This invention marked a pivotal moment, shifting the source of power from human muscle to the electric grid.

However, these early electric routers were “portable” in name only. They were massive, heavy beasts, with some models during the World War I era weighing around 35 lbs (15.8 kg). Despite their heft, their utility was undeniable. A New York pattern maker named R.L. Carter began mass-producing these machines, which became known as the “wonder tool”. Over a decade, his company manufactured over 100,000 routers before being acquired by Stanley Electric Tools in the 1930s, a move that helped cement the tool’s place in the mainstream woodworking world.

Key Innovations and Diversification

The mid-20th century saw a period of rapid innovation that defined the modern router’s form and function. The most significant of these was the invention of the plunge router by the German company Elu (now part of DeWalt) in 1949. Unlike a fixed-base router, where the cutting depth is set and locked, the plunge router’s motor and bit could move up and down on spring-loaded shafts. This seemingly simple change was revolutionary, as it allowed an operator to start a cut in the middle of a workpiece, dramatically expanding the tool’s versatility for tasks like creating mortises or stopped grooves.

This period also saw the diversification of the tool into distinct categories to suit different tasks. The market now included the versatile plunge router, the stable fixed-base router, and a smaller, more nimble category known as the “trim router” or “laminate trimmer”. Originally designed for trimming the edges of plastic laminate on countertops, these compact routers became prized for their light weight and one-handed operation, making them ideal for edge-profiling and other delicate tasks. This is the direct historical lineage from which the Ryobi P601 descends. Alongside the evolution of the handheld tool, the router table also emerged, first as a shop-improvised solution where woodworkers would mount a router upside-down beneath a table, and later as a commercially produced accessory that further expanded the tool’s capabilities for precision work.

This century-long evolution reveals a clear and consistent trajectory. The history of the router is not merely a story of adding more power, but of a relentless march toward making that power more controllable, safer, and accessible to a wider audience. The first step was reducing the sheer physical burden; early routers were so heavy they limited their use to the strongest and most skilled professionals. The adoption of new materials, such as lightweight alloys and durable plastics, was a critical development, bringing the weight of even the largest modern routers down to around 14 lbs (6.3 kg)—less than half that of their early predecessors. The second step was taming the power. The introduction of features like variable speed control and soft-start motors, which prevent the tool from jerking on startup, made these high-speed machines “much safer and easier to use”. The development of the compact trim router format, and ultimately the cordless Ryobi P601, represents the logical conclusion of this trend. It takes the fundamental power of a workshop staple and packages it in a form that is as lightweight, portable, and non-intimidating as possible. The P601 is not just a product of new battery technology; it is the culmination of a century-long design philosophy aimed at democratizing a once-specialized and dangerous tool.
 Ryobi P601 Cordless Compact Router

Section 2: The Science of Cord-Cutting: Anatomy of a Modern Power Tool

The liberation from the power cord was not a single breakthrough but the result of parallel advancements in two distinct fields of science: electrochemistry and motor engineering. The Ryobi P601, like all modern cordless tools, sits at the intersection of these two technologies. Understanding them is essential to understanding the tool’s performance, its price, and its place in the market.

The Nobel Prize in Your Toolbox: The Lithium-Ion Revolution

The unassuming battery pack that clicks into the base of the P601 is a marvel of modern chemistry, the result of decades of research that earned its key developers the 2019 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. The lithium-ion (Li-ion) battery fundamentally changed the calculus of portable power, making tools like a high-speed cordless router not just possible, but practical.

At its core, a Li-ion battery operates through a precisely controlled chemical dance. When the tool is switched on, a discharge cycle begins. Inside the battery, lithium atoms stored in the negative electrode, or anode (typically made of graphite), are ionized—they lose an electron. These newly formed, positively charged lithium ions then begin a journey. They move from the anode, through a liquid chemical solution called the

electrolyte, and pass through a micro-permeable separator—a critical barrier that allows ions to pass but prevents the electrodes from touching and causing a short circuit. The ions complete their journey at the positive electrode, or

cathode (typically a metal oxide), where they recombine with electrons. Crucially, the electrons they shed at the anode are not allowed to pass through the separator. Instead, they are forced to travel through an external circuit—the motor of the router—to meet the ions at the cathode. This flow of electrons through the tool’s motor is the electrical current that provides power. When the battery is recharged, an external power source reverses this process, forcing the ions and electrons back to the anode, ready for the next cycle.

This elegant process conferred several game-changing advantages over older rechargeable battery technologies like nickel-cadmium (Ni-Cd) or lead-acid.

  • High Energy Density: Lithium is the third-lightest element, possessing a small atomic weight and radius. This allows Li-ion batteries to pack significantly more energy into a smaller, lighter package. They can achieve energy densities as high as 330 watt-hours per kilogram (Wh/kg), compared to just 75 Wh/kg for lead-acid batteries. This is the key property that allows for powerful tools that are not excessively heavy or bulky.
  • High Voltage: A single Li-ion cell can deliver up to 3.6 volts, roughly three times the voltage of a Ni-Cd cell. This makes them ideal for the high-power demands of tools like routers.
  • No “Memory Effect”: Older Ni-Cd batteries suffered from a detrimental process where repeated partial discharge cycles could cause the battery to “remember” a lower capacity. Li-ion batteries have no memory effect, meaning they can be topped off at any time without degrading their long-term capacity, a massive convenience for the intermittent use patterns of a workshop.
  • Low Self-Discharge: When left on a shelf, a Li-ion battery loses only about 1.5–2% of its charge per month, ensuring it’s ready to work when needed.

These advantages combined to create the perfect power source for the cordless tool revolution, providing the energy, longevity, and convenience that craftsmen had long desired.
 Ryobi P601 Cordless Compact Router

The Heart of the Machine: A Tale of Two Motors

Once the battery delivers its electrical current, it’s up to the motor to convert that energy into the rotational motion that spins the router bit. In the world of modern cordless tools, there are two dominant designs: the traditional brushed motor and the more advanced brushless motor. The choice between them is one of the most significant engineering trade-offs a manufacturer can make, directly impacting a tool’s performance, lifespan, and, most critically, its cost.

The Classic Workhorse: The Brushed Motor

The brushed DC motor is a venerable technology that has been a reliable workhorse for over a century. Its operation is based on a simple, direct mechanical principle. Inside the motor, stationary permanent magnets form the outer casing, or

stator. The rotating central part, or rotor, contains electromagnets. To make the rotor spin, electricity from the battery must be delivered to these electromagnets. This is achieved by a pair of small carbon blocks, known as brushes, which are in constant physical contact with a segmented copper sleeve on the rotor called the commutator. As the rotor spins, the brushes slide over the commutator segments, continuously reversing the polarity of the electromagnets, which keeps them pushing and pulling against the permanent magnets of the stator, thereby sustaining the rotation.

The primary advantages of this design are its simplicity and low cost. Brushed motors are relatively inexpensive to manufacture, which makes the tools they power more affordable for the end consumer. However, this elegant simplicity comes at a cost. The physical friction between the brushes and the spinning commutator is a constant source of inefficiency. This friction generates heat, which is wasted energy that could have been used to power the tool, thus reducing overall battery runtime. This friction also causes the carbon brushes to physically wear down over time, eventually requiring replacement to keep the tool operational.

The Modern Challenger: The Brushless Motor

The brushless DC motor, which became commercially viable with the advent of solid-state electronics in the 1960s, represents a significant technological leap forward. The design essentially flips the brushed motor inside out. The permanent magnets are now located on the spinning rotor, while the electromagnets are fixed in place on the stator. With no need to deliver current to a spinning component, the brushes and commutator are eliminated entirely.

In their place is a small electronic controller, a printed circuit board assembly (PCBA), that acts as the “brain” of the tool. This controller uses sensors to monitor the position of the rotor and then intelligently switches the electromagnets on and off in a precise sequence, creating a rotating magnetic field that pulls the permanent magnets on the rotor along with it.

The benefits of this design are substantial. By eliminating the friction of the brushes, brushless motors are significantly more energy-efficient, converting more of the battery’s electricity into useful work. This translates directly to longer runtime on a single charge—often a 50% improvement. They also run cooler, generate more torque, and have a much longer operational lifespan because there are no brushes to wear out. Many brushless tools also feature “smart” electronics that can adjust power output based on the load, delivering more current when cutting through a dense material to maintain speed. The main disadvantage is cost. The sophisticated electronic controller makes brushless motors more complex and expensive to produce, which is reflected in the higher price of the tools that use them.

The Ryobi P601 is equipped with a brushed motor. This is not because Ryobi lacks the capability to produce brushless tools; its premium “HP” line is built around advanced brushless technology. Rather, the selection of a brushed motor for the P601 is a conscious and critical engineering decision. The primary goal for this specific tool was not to achieve maximum power or the longest possible runtime, but to hit an exceptionally aggressive price point of $69. The lower manufacturing cost of the brushed motor is the single most important factor that makes this price possible. This decision perfectly encapsulates the P601’s entire value proposition: it deliberately sacrifices the objectively “better” technology to achieve the “best” price for its target market, the budget-conscious DIYer. This fundamental trade-off—performance for price—is the defining characteristic of the tool.

Section 3: Under the Microscope: The Ryobi P601 Trim Router

Armed with an understanding of the historical and technological context, we can now place the Ryobi P601 itself under the microscope. An analysis of its design, performance, and features reveals a tool built around a series of deliberate compromises, blending surprisingly premium features with noticeable limitations to deliver on its core promise of cordless convenience at an unbeatable price.

Design and Ergonomics

At first glance, the P601 follows the traditional design language of a trim router, but with the unmistakable addition of a large battery dock on top. It is constructed with a sturdy, die-cast aluminum base, which provides stability and accuracy during cuts, paired with a durable plastic motor housing in Ryobi’s signature “hyper green” color. One of its most notable physical attributes is its light weight. At just 2.8 pounds without a battery, it is among the lighter cordless options on the market, a key factor for reducing user fatigue during extended use.

The in-hand feel of the tool has drawn mixed reactions. While the top-mounted battery can give the router an awkward, top-heavy appearance, most professional reviewers have noted that it does not feel significantly off-balance during typical routing operations. However, some users report that it can indeed feel unbalanced, particularly when paired with a larger, heavier battery pack like a 4.0 Ah or 9.0 Ah model. The tool features a rubberized “GripZone” overmold intended to enhance comfort, but its placement high on the motor housing is often not where users naturally place their hands for control; most tend to grip the tool lower down, around the base.

Despite these minor ergonomic quirks, the P601 incorporates several user-facing features that are surprisingly well-executed for a tool in this price category:

  • Depth Adjustment: The mechanism for setting the cutting depth is a standout feature, praised by users and reviewers alike for its simplicity and effectiveness. It uses a tried-and-true system combining a quick-release lever for large, rapid “macro” adjustments with a dedicated thumbwheel for precise “micro” adjustments, allowing users to easily dial in a specific cutting depth.
  • LED Light: An integrated LED work light is positioned near the collet, illuminating the cutting area. This is a feature often found on more expensive, professional-grade tools, and its inclusion here significantly improves visibility of the bit and the workpiece, especially in poorly lit conditions.
  • Bit Changes: The design of the base and the placement of the spindle lock button allow for 1/4-inch shank router bits to be changed without having to completely remove the base from the motor housing. When the tool is inverted for this task, the flat bottom of the battery provides a remarkably stable platform to rest on, a small but thoughtful design touch that users appreciate.

Performance Evaluation

The performance of the P601 is a direct reflection of its internal hardware. As established, it is powered by a brushed motor that operates at a single, fixed speed of 29,000 RPM (rotations per minute) with no load. This speed is notably high for a budget tool; in fact, it is 3,500 RPM faster than the maximum speed of the more expensive DeWalt DCW600B cordless router.

In real-world applications, this combination of a high-speed brushed motor translates to a specific performance profile. The P601 excels at light-duty and medium-duty tasks, particularly in softer woods. Performance tests and user reviews consistently show it performing admirably when creating edge profiles with roundover or chamfer bits, trimming laminate and veneer, or cutting shallow grooves and dadoes in materials like pine. For the vast majority of common DIY and home woodworking projects, its power is more than sufficient.

The tool’s limitations become apparent when it is pushed into more demanding applications. The combination of a brushed motor (which has less torque than a brushless equivalent) and the lack of variable speed control means the P601 struggles when working with dense hardwoods or using larger bits for aggressive cuts. Under these heavy loads, the motor can begin to bog down, losing speed and causing the bit to burn the wood rather than cut it cleanly. The consensus among experienced users is that the P601 is an excellent choice for work in soft to medium woods, but should be reserved for light edge work only when dealing with hardwoods like oak or maple.

A Deliberate Omission: The Missing Dust Port

Perhaps the most significant design compromise on the P601 is the complete lack of any provision for dust collection. This is a notable omission, as routers are infamous for producing enormous quantities of dust, including very fine particles that pose a respiratory hazard and can coat an entire workshop in a thin film.

This omission, however, is likely another calculated decision driven by cost. Effective dust collection on a handheld router is an engineering challenge. The high-speed bit spins at up to 29,000 RPM, ejecting chips and fine dust in every direction with considerable force. Unlike stationary tools like a table saw, which has a cabinet to help contain debris, a handheld router operates in an open-air environment, making it difficult to create the focused airflow needed to capture dust at its source. Implementing an effective dust collection system requires carefully designed shrouds that enclose the bit, integrated ports to connect a vacuum hose, and sometimes complex internal baffles to direct airflow. Each of these components adds to the tool’s physical size, its complexity, and, most importantly, its manufacturing cost. By omitting a dust port entirely, Ryobi was able to keep the P601’s design simpler and its price lower.

The P601 is the embodiment of “good enough” engineering. Its design represents a masterclass in feature triage, where every component and capability was weighed against its impact on the final price. Ryobi clearly invested in the features that are absolutely critical to the core user experience of a trim router. A router that cannot be adjusted with precision is fundamentally useless, so the P601 was given a robust and well-regarded depth adjustment system. A router that prevents the user from seeing their cut line is frustrating and inaccurate, so an LED light—a premium feature—was included.

Conversely, the features that were stripped out are those that separate a basic, functional tool from a high-performance, professional-grade one. Variable speed control, the superior power and efficiency of a brushless motor, and integrated dust collection are all “nice-to-have” features that professionals demand but that would have added significant cost, pushing the tool far beyond its target sub-$70 price bracket. The result is a tool that perfectly executes the concept of a “minimum viable product.” It performs the most common tasks its target user will ask of it, and it performs them well enough to deliver a satisfying experience, all while providing the freedom of cordless operation at a price that makes it an easy, almost impulsive purchase for anyone already invested in its battery ecosystem.

Section 4: The Power of the Platform: Understanding the ONE+ Ecosystem

To fully appreciate the Ryobi P601, one must look beyond the tool itself and examine the ecosystem in which it exists. The router’s greatest strength is not its motor or its depth adjustment mechanism, but the simple fact that it is part of the Ryobi 18V ONE+ system. This platform strategy is the key to Ryobi’s market success and is the context that gives a $69 bare tool its true value.

The History of ONE+

The Ryobi brand has a long and varied history, originating in Japan in 1943 as a manufacturer of die-cast products. The company entered the power tool market in 1968 and gradually expanded its offerings. A pivotal moment in the brand’s modern history occurred in August 2000, when the Hong Kong-based conglomerate Techtronic Industries (TTI) acquired Ryobi’s North American power tools business. This acquisition is crucial for understanding Ryobi’s market position, as TTI is also the parent company of Milwaukee Tool, a brand renowned for its high-performance, professional-grade cordless tools. This dual ownership allows TTI to execute a clear market segmentation strategy: Milwaukee targets the demanding professional contractor, while Ryobi is positioned as the high-value, feature-rich brand for DIY enthusiasts and budget-conscious users.

Long before the TTI acquisition, however, Ryobi made a strategic decision that would become the bedrock of its future success. In 1996, the company launched its 18V battery system. While the “ONE+” branding was officially adopted later (around 2004), the physical battery interface introduced in 1996 has remained unchanged.

The Core Promise: Unwavering Compatibility

The single most important strategic decision governing the ONE+ system is a promise Ryobi has made to its customers: they will never change the 18V ONE+ battery platform. This commitment to backward and forward compatibility is a massive differentiator in the power tool market. It means that a new ONE+ battery purchased today will fit and power a Ryobi 18V tool manufactured in 1996, and an original battery from 1996 (if it still holds a charge) will work in the latest high-tech Ryobi tool. This promise fosters enormous long-term value and brand loyalty, as customers can invest in the system with the confidence that their expensive batteries will not be rendered obsolete by the next product cycle.

The Scale of the System

The longevity of the ONE+ platform has allowed it to grow to a staggering scale. Today, the ONE+ ecosystem comprises over 300 unique products that all operate on the same 18V battery. The breadth of this system is its defining characteristic. It extends far beyond the traditional workshop tools like drills, saws, and sanders. The ONE+ battery can also power a vast array of outdoor and lifestyle products, including lawnmowers, string trimmers, leaf blowers, pressure washers, vacuums, portable fans, coolers, radios, and even a floating Bluetooth speaker for a swimming pool. This incredible versatility transforms the battery from a simple power source for a single tool into a universal energy platform for the entire home and garden.

The Economics of a Single Platform

This single-platform approach creates a powerful economic incentive loop for consumers. The primary advantages are convenience and cost savings. A user only needs one type of battery and one charger for hundreds of potential tools. More importantly, it allows them to purchase subsequent tools as cheaper “bare tool” versions, without the added cost of a bundled battery and charger. This dramatically lowers the barrier to entry for acquiring new capabilities.

The primary disadvantage of this model is the phenomenon of “vendor lock-in”. Once a consumer has invested a significant amount of money in several ONE+ batteries and a collection of tools, the financial and practical cost of switching to a competing brand’s ecosystem becomes prohibitively high. Even if a competitor releases a single tool that is objectively superior, the user is heavily incentivized to stick with the “good enough” Ryobi version to maintain compatibility with their existing battery collection. Furthermore, while the platform is consistent, the batteries themselves are consumable items with a finite lifespan; they degrade over time and with use, eventually requiring replacement, which represents a long-term cost.

Viewed through this strategic lens, the Ryobi P601’s role becomes crystal clear. It is not just a router; it is a highly effective customer acquisition tool—a “gateway drug” for the entire ONE+ ecosystem. A trim router is a versatile and desirable tool that many DIYers and aspiring woodworkers want, but they might be hesitant to purchase a more expensive corded model or a premium cordless version from a competitor. Ryobi leverages this desire by pricing the P601 at an impulse-buy level of just $69 for the bare tool. This irresistibly low price entices a new user to make their first investment in the ONE+ platform, perhaps by purchasing the router along with a starter kit containing a battery and charger.

Once that initial purchase is made, the economic calculus for all future tool purchases is altered. The financial barrier to acquiring their next Ryobi tool is now dramatically lower, as they can simply buy the bare tool. The sheer scale of the 300+ tool system ensures that there will almost certainly be another tool—a sander, a nailer, a leaf blower—that the user will want or need in the future. The promise of unwavering compatibility provides the peace of mind that their initial battery investment is secure. The P601’s design trade-offs—its “good enough” performance at an unbeatable price—are perfectly calibrated to serve this strategic role. Its primary purpose is not just to shape wood, but to onboard new customers into the vast, profitable, and remarkably “sticky” ONE+ platform.

Section 5: Sizing Up the Competition: Value vs. High-Performance

While the Ryobi P601 carves out a dominant position in the value segment of the market, it does not exist in a vacuum. For woodworkers and DIYers willing to invest more for enhanced performance and features, the market offers several compelling alternatives. The most direct competitors are the DeWalt DCW600B and the Makita XTR01Z, two models that represent the next tier up in both price and capability. A direct comparison reveals the specific trade-offs a user makes when choosing between the P601’s accessibility and the advanced technology of its rivals.

The Technology Gap

The most significant technological differentiator lies under the hood. Both the DeWalt DCW600B and the Makita XTR01Z are built around advanced brushless motors. As previously discussed, this technology is inherently more efficient, delivering more power under load, running cooler, and offering a longer potential lifespan than the P601’s brushed motor. This superior motor technology is a primary justification for their higher price points, which are typically more than double that of the Ryobi.

This advanced motor is paired with more sophisticated electronics. Both the DeWalt and Makita models offer variable speed control, typically via a dial that allows the user to adjust the bit’s rotational speed. This is a critical feature for serious woodworking, as it enables the operator to match the speed to the specific bit and material. Slower speeds are necessary for larger diameter bits to reduce chatter and are often preferred for hardwoods to prevent burning the wood—a common issue with the single-speed P601.

Furthermore, the premium competitors include a suite of features designed to enhance safety and control, which the P601 lacks. These often include an electronic brake, which rapidly slows the spinning bit the moment the tool is switched off, and a soft-start feature, which gradually ramps the motor up to full speed to prevent the tool from jerking in the user’s hands on startup. The Makita also boasts electronic speed control, which actively supplies more power to the motor to maintain a constant RPM even when the tool is under a heavy load.

The Specifications Showdown Table

To provide a clear, at-a-glance comparison of these hardware differences, the key technical specifications of the three routers are summarized below. This data-driven overview allows for an objective evaluation of the trade-offs between the models, highlighting how differences in motor technology, features, and design philosophy translate into tangible performance characteristics.

Metric Ryobi P601 DeWalt DCW600B Makita XTR01Z
Motor Type Brushed Brushless Brushless
Voltage 18V 20V MAX* 18V
No-Load Speed (RPM) 29,000 16,000 - 25,500 10,000 - 30,000
Speed Control Single Speed Variable Dial Variable Dial
Collet Size 1/4” 1/4” 1/4”
Weight (Bare Tool) 2.8 lbs 4.1 lbs 4.6 lbs (with battery)
Key Features LED Light Dual LEDs, Electronic Brake, Soft Start Dual LEDs, Electronic Speed Control, Soft Start
Plunge Base Compatible No Yes Yes
MSRP (Bare Tool) $69 ~$150 ~$142

Data compiled from sources:.

*Note: DeWalt’s 20V MAX system operates at a nominal voltage of 18V.

The Verdict

The data makes the choice clear, but it is not a matter of which router is objectively “best.” Instead, the decision hinges entirely on the user’s needs, budget, and existing tool collection.

The Ryobi P601 is the undeniable winner for the user prioritizing price and value above all else. For the DIYer who needs a router for occasional edge-profiling, trimming, and light-duty work in softwoods, its performance is more than adequate. For anyone already invested in the Ryobi ONE+ ecosystem, its $69 price tag makes it an almost irresistible addition to their collection.

The DeWalt DCW600B and Makita XTR01Z are, by nearly every technical measure, superior tools. Their brushless motors, variable speed control, and advanced safety features provide a level of power, versatility, and refinement that the Ryobi cannot match. They can handle a wider range of materials, including hardwoods, and are compatible with accessories like plunge bases that significantly expand their capabilities. They are the better choice for the serious hobbyist, the aspiring professional, or anyone who frequently works with hardwoods and demands greater precision and control from their tools. The premium they command in price is a direct investment in that higher level of performance.

Section 6: Conclusion: The P601’s Place in the Evolving Workshop

The Ryobi P601 One+ 18V Cordless Trim Router, when viewed in isolation, is a competent but unremarkable tool. It is when we place it within the broader context of technological evolution, engineering economics, and market strategy that its true significance emerges. This unassuming green router is far more than the sum of its parts; it is a product of deliberate and intelligent compromise, a physical manifestation of the forces shaping the modern workshop.

Its existence is predicated on a century-long historical trend of making the formidable power of the router safer, lighter, and more accessible to the average user. Its cordless freedom is powered by the Nobel Prize-winning science of the lithium-ion battery, a technology that redefined the limits of portable power. Its performance characteristics and, most critically, its price, are dictated by the calculated economic choice to use a traditional brushed motor instead of a more advanced but costly brushless one. And its greatest strength lies not in its own intrinsic capabilities, but in its strategic role as an affordable and compelling entry point into the sprawling, 300+ tool Ryobi ONE+ ecosystem.

The P601 represents the triumph of “good enough” engineering. In a market often fixated on pushing the boundaries of peak performance and professional-grade features, the success of the P601 demonstrates the immense and often underestimated power of accessibility. By consciously sacrificing the high-end features that drive up costs, Ryobi has created a tool that empowers a massive segment of the population. It enables aspiring makers, homeowners, and hobbyists to take up woodworking and DIY projects that might otherwise have been financially or technically out of reach. It lowers the barrier to entry not just for a single task, but for an entire system of creative potential.

In the end, the bright green Ryobi P601 is a potent symbol of the modern workshop itself—a space where the lines between professional and amateur are increasingly blurred, where the freedom from the cord is paramount, and where the smartest tool is not always the most powerful or the most expensive. It is a testament to the idea that sometimes, the most revolutionary act is not to invent something entirely new, but to take something powerful and make it affordable enough for everyone. It is a tool designed not just to make dust, but to make creators.